9 Pairs of One Tree Hill Members That Gave Love a Try in Real Life

By  | 

Nathan Scott & Haley James are #relationshipgoals. When he gave her that bracelet from a Cracker Jack box and said, “Don’t say I never gave you anything,” we’re pretty sure we died a little inside. Death by swooning. UNFORTUNATELY, the people who brought Nathan & Haley to life on the small screen, James Lafferty & Bethany Joy Lenz, never gave real-life love a try. What gives, guys??

The silver lining: other fan favorites from One Tree Hill did! Yes, the hot people who played Lucas, Brooke, Quinn, Clay, Chase & more dated their OTH co-stars, giving way to major OTPs. Here are nine such pairings: